Assicurazioni Generali (BIT:GASI) has announced robust financial results for the full year of 2023, marking a period of profitable growth and significant value creation for shareholders. The insurer reported a record operating result of €6.9 billion, a 7.9% rise from the previous year, and an adjusted net result of €3.6 billion, increasing by 14.1%.
The Property & Casualty (P&C) segment was a primary contributor to top-line growth, with notable improvements in motor and non-motor lines. Generali's focus on a customer-centric approach has paid off, with the achievement of its multi-holding customer goal ahead of time.
The company is set to propose an increased dividend of €1.28 per share and a share buyback program worth €500 million, pending approval. Looking forward, Generali remains confident in reaching its financial targets, with a continued emphasis on sustainability and growth.
Key Takeaways
- Generali reported a record operating result of €6.9 billion for 2023, up by 7.9%.
- Adjusted net result increased by 14.1% to €3.6 billion.
- The P&C segment drove the growth, with motor and non-motor insurance lines performing well.
- Generali achieved its multi-holding customer goal ahead of schedule.
- The company plans to distribute an increased dividend of €1.28 per share and a €500 million share buyback.
- The company has a strong focus on sustainability and future growth.
Company Outlook
- Generali anticipates continued achievement of financial goals.
- The insurer plans to maintain its focus on sustainability and growth.
- There is a commitment to shareholder-friendly policies, including dividends and share buybacks.
- Generali aims to strengthen its European insurance operations and expand global asset management.
- Positive life insurance flows are expected in 2024 with competitive product offerings.
Bearish Highlights
- Higher natural catastrophes in 2023 impacted discounting and claims.
- A high double-digit or triple-digit loss in income is expected due to reduced market performance in 2023.
Bullish Highlights
- Strong pricing movement, particularly in motor insurance, with plans to continue rate increases in non-motor insurance.
- The company is tracking ahead of inflation in non-motor insurance.
- Retention rates are good, and risk in force is stable or slightly growing.
- Generali plans to keep debt leverage constant through 2024.
Misses
- Lower operating capital generation in 2023 was reported due to natural catastrophes and discounting effects.
Q&A Highlights
- The CFO provided details on prudent reservation, discounting, and unwinding, which improved predictability and reduced risk on capital.
- The potential impact of geopolitical events on the Solvency 2 ratio was discussed, emphasizing resilience and diversification of cash flow sources.
- The CEO and CFO discussed the company's disciplined and selective approach to M&A.
- The company expects to achieve the same level of operating capital generation in 2024 and potentially exceed it by over 5%.
Generali's focus on disciplined capital management and strategic growth initiatives have positioned the company for continued success. The commitment to a customer-centric strategy, combined with prudent financial management, has enabled Generali to navigate market challenges and deliver value to shareholders.
As the company moves forward, it remains dedicated to enhancing its product offerings and maintaining a strong capital position, while also exploring opportunities for expansion and innovation.
Full transcript - Assicurazioni Generali (GASI) Q4 2023:
Operator: Good morning or good afternoon. This is the chorus call conference operator. Welcome and thank you for joining the Generali Group Full Year 2023 Results Presentation Conference Call. As a reminder, all participants are in listen-only mode. After the presentation, there will be opportunity to ask question. [Operator Instructions] At this time, I would like to turn the conference over to Mr. Fabio Cleva Head of Investor and Rating Agency Relations. Please go ahead sir.
Fabio Cleva: Thank you, operator. Hello everyone and welcome to Assicurazioni Generali full year 2023 results presentation. Here with us today we have our Group CEO, Philippe Donnet; our Group General Manager, Marco Sesana; and our Group CFO, Cristiano Borean. Before we open the Q&A session, let me hand it over to our Group CEO for some opening remarks. Philippe, the floor is yours.
Philippe Donnet: Thank you, Fabio and thanks to all of you for joining this call. Our full year financial results for 2023 confirm once more Generali strong position and continued progress towards the delivery of our current strategic plan. Even in a challenging environment, our group continued to drive profitable growth and create sustainable value for all stakeholders. Furthermore, this excellent performance does not yet reflect the positive impact from the acquisitions of Liberty Seguros and Conning Holdings and its affiliates. These acquisitions will provide us with a further boost as we strengthen our insurance leadership in Europe and continue to build a global asset management platform. Before we open the call for questions, I want to highlight four key messages. First, we delivered record results with a positive contribution from all business segments. Our record operating results of €6.9 billion is up by 7.9% compared to full year 2022. Our adjusted net results also rose to a record level of €3.6 billion with a very strong increase of 14.1%. Since 2016, the growth of the group's operating results has vastly outpaced that of the top line. This is a clear demonstration of our focus on profitable growth as well as of Generali successful transformation from a predominantly Life insurer to a diversified insurance and asset management group. My second message is about Property & Casualty, which has been the key driver of our top line growth with both motor and non-motor lines recording a positive performance. Property & Casualty was also the key driver of our operating result to record levels. The tariff strengthening measures we have implemented are driving an acceleration in our annual average premium growth. Also the undiscounted attritional combined ratio is showing tangible improvement across different time periods. My third key message is about customers. We are continuing to work hard to achieve our lifetime partner ambition and we recorded further progress in 2023. We confirmed the number one position in our peer group in terms of relationship Net Promoted Score and looking at our multi-holding customer goal, we closed the year with over 50% of customers entrusting Generali to cover at least two of their insurance needs. This exceeds the ambition we had set for year-end 2024. Being as close as possible to our customers is a key pillar of our strategy and a distinctive feature of Generali as the largest insurance for retail and SME customers in Europe. Thanks to our continued and significant investment in our distribution and our customer-centric value proposition, we have a unique ability to benefit from the positive dynamics we are seeing in personnel lines. This is also visible in our Life business where protection and unit-linked continued to record positive net inflows that we're close to €9 billion at the end of 2023, despite a challenging market environment. We are confident that if market conditions continue to improve throughout 2024, we will come back to positive net inflows in Life. Our leading proprietary distribution network, which is the channel closest to customers, will be instrumental to achieve this. The fourth key message is, about our continued commitment to shareholder remuneration. Following these excellent results and thanks to the very healthy cash generation and solid capital position, we are proposing an increased dividend of €1.28 per share. We have been distributing an attractive, predictable and steadily growing dividend since I was appointed group CEO. This year's dividend is over 10% higher than the one we paid last year, and 60% higher than the one Generali paid in 2016. With this dividend, we also reach our 2022-2024 cumulative dividend target at €5.5 billion. Our focus on shareholders' remuneration is also demonstrated by the €500 million share buyback, we plan to implement this year, subject to AGM approval. With that in mind, in the time horizon of our current plan, we will pay to our shareholders, a total amount of €6.5 billion between dividends and share buybacks. This is over 20% of the market cap we had, when the plan started. On top of that, starting from 2023, we have decided to offset any dilutive impact from long-term incentive plans, through share buybacks. As I said at our Investor Day going forward, we will look for the most efficient balance between M&A and shareholders remuneration, on a yearly basis, possibly even with annual buybacks. To close, we keep working on the successful delivery of our Lifetime Partner 24 driving growth strategy, and we are fully on track to achieve the remaining two key financial goals of the plan. Furthermore, we continue to develop our business particularly, when it comes to integrating sustainability, the originator of our current plan into everything we do, as a responsible investor, insurer, employer and corporate citizen. My focus and that of the other members of the Group Management Committee, is also increasingly shifting to the next strategic cycle. With Generali in the best shape it has ever been as a profitable diversified insurance and asset management player, this is the ideal starting point for the next plan. And it gives me and my team great energy passion and enthusiasm, to write the next chapter of our sustainable growth story. I thank you once more for your attention and for your interest in our Group, and I'm now happy to take all your questions together, with Cristiano and Marco.
Operator: This is the Chorus Call conference operator. We will now begin the question-and-answer session [Operator Instructions] The first question is from David Barma of Bank of America. Please go ahead.
Q – David Barma: Good morning. Thank you for taking my questions. The first one is on P&C, where it's great to see the strong improvement in the underlying loss ratio in 4Q. Can you run us through, what has changed in the last quarter versus earlier in the year, please? And with that in mind, normalizing for the higher nat cats that you had in 2023 and adding some of the pricing effect that should come through in 2024, you should be able to get quite a bit lower than your 96% targets. So, what kind of other headwinds or potential volatile items should we have in mind for 2024? And my second question, maybe linked to that, is that now that the Liberty Seguros deal has closed, can you give us a bit more detail in your assumptions for the contribution of Liberty Seguros on your 2024 targets, please? I have a question on cash as well linked to Switzerland. So you've been adding to reserve for a few years. The interest rate situation has changed a bit. And are you able to give us an update on what your plans are for reserving in Switzerland, please and whether we might be able to start seeing some dividends come out of that unit? Thank you.
Fabio Cleva: Thank you very much, David. Cristiano, the three questions are all for you. And Marco of course, if you want to add on the underlying trends in the P&C, feel free to do so at the end.
Cristiano Borean: Hello, David. Good morning, all. So first of all the underlying loss ratio improvement in the fourth quarter versus what we observed in the first nine months. I think we provided a very detailed evolution already in the first part of the document put on the web. But what you can see is that there is a clear improvement overall in the fourth quarter versus the first nine months in the so-called current year loss ratio, attritional, undiscounted taking off the nat cat, which is decreasing by 1.5 percentage point compared in the fourth quarter compared to the first nine months, which is driven also this half and notwithstanding a slightly higher increase of man-made from 1.7 to 1.9 in the fourth quarter, 1.9 versus 1.7 in the first nine months. This is a good driver of evolution but was also a reduction on the acquisition expenses in the fourth quarter overall versus the first nine months, which is driving an overall improvement of the current year in particular combined ratio attritional undiscounted of 2.4 percentage points. So taking off the nat cat this number is. So we moved from 96.6% in the first nine months to 94.2% in the only quarter view only of 2023. So minus 2.4 percentage point. So outlook, are we going better than what I told you end of January? So what we are saying is always when we set an ambition and a target, we try always to give a target and try to overachieve it. Clearly, what we are measuring so far is related to the fact that we are putting on all the necessary technical measures to adapt to any imbalance which is dynamically observed in every single geography. We are growing the non-motor at a faster way, and this is allowing us to have better profitability as well because the two segments, the best one is the non-motor as usual. And clearly this is bringing us confidence on what you said, and we will manage it accordingly. Regarding the second question of Liberty Seguros, yes, it has been closed but still the balance sheet has to be the local gap balance sheet of the year 2023 has to be approved. So we are still waiting to have the final approval of this to start digging into the numbers and understanding and aligning those figures with our Group figure. I just recalled you one important sensitivity, five percentage point more combined ratio of Liberty Seguros versus the Group one means 20 basis point deterioration of group combined ratio. This is the sensitivity we should have in mind. On the third question, what is happening in Switzerland? Actually it is happening a very important and positive thing because let me say, number one, already when we started in 2023 with the opening balance 2023 published, we were adopting the IFRS 17 number which is a common international standard practice, which is already reflecting the value of the portfolio and the natural unwinding on the release ratio of it. On top of this, due to the fact that the discussion with the regulator was on the local gap reserving, we closed at year-end an agreement in order to have a very prudent reservation. But as well, we are out of any form of specific reservation. And on top of that, this is allowing us to have much more predictability. This was done through a very specifically implemented detail underway still in 2024 project of ALM, which is allowing us to have a much less sensitivity, much better predictability and going forward allowing less trap or risk on capital. So far this is a very positive improvement achieved.
Fabio Cleva: Next question please.
Operator: The next question is from Michael Huttner of Berenberg. Please go ahead.
Michael Huttner: Fantastic. Thank you so much. It's a lovely result, it's really lovely. It was hard to find any questions which were challenging, but here it goes. Can you give us the balance of discounting and undiscounting for 2024? I worked out and I am probably wrong that in 2022 it was plus €500 million, so the discounting plus the unwind of the discount was positive that year, 2023 was plus €520 million and my guess applies for 2024, so considering both the discounting and the unwinding of the discount, it drops to €250 million, so there is a headwind of €270 million, so just to check those figures? The second is on the pricing, so can you give us a feel for the pricing in Q1? I know the pricing has been really strong in 2023, but it's average pricing, so I am interested in the kind of more momentum figure if you have anything? And then the last one is really, really, really tricky, it's not negative, but something one of your peers said last night. If you were to run a very extreme scenario. And I really apologize for kind of troubling the waters, it's not the time to think of such scenarios, but you know something happening in Taiwan, where would your solvency with today's 212%, where would it land? Thank you.
Philippe Donnet: Thank you very much, Michael. May we just please ask you to repeat the third question, which if I understand correctly was about geopolitical implications on the Solvency 2 ratio, is that correct?
Michael Huttner: That's exactly right. That's exactly right.
Philippe Donnet: Okay. Thank you very much. So Cristiano, the first question is for you. The second question on pricing in PNC in the first quarter is for Marco, while the third one on the solvency is again for you, Cristiano.
Cristiano Borean: Yes. So, hello, Michael. First of all, balance between discounting and unwinding. You are perfectly right, I give you the number. We had €463 million of current year discounting in 2022 and we have €814 million of current year discounting in 2023. And this is clearly creating a €351 million delta from one year to the other. So this year we were positively benefiting from that. But when I look on the unwinding, the so-called insurance finance expansion related to the unwinding of the leak, I have a negative delta, so on relative the delta between the extra cost in 2023 versus the cost on 2022 is €186 million because we ended up with something which was unwinding before of negative rates still in 2022 versus unwinding of positive rates in 2023. Going forward, this effect would mean for 2024, all else equal with rates which we are serving, you should get less than €800 million, maybe closer to the €700 million discounting expected in 2024, while the unwinding number should increase to €565 million of EC related only to the unwinding on the leak, which is basically representing something in the order of €250 million more compared to this year. This is why if you look at the overall P&L effect, the benefit of this year is reflected in a higher, let's call it a hurdle to be overcome next year and the driver for this is exactly what I told before to David, which is the current year attritional improvement in the business we are underwriting.
Michael Huttner: Thank you. Thank you, Cristiano.
Marco Sesana: Hi, Michael. And hi, everyone. So, talking about pricing in the fourth quarter, so we still see a strong movement in tariff in the first quarter. Let me, as usual, clarify and give you a little bit more perspective on what we do. So as you know, we move our pricing and our, let's say portfolio restructuring based on how the risk premium is moving. Risk premium is a combination of frequency and severity that is impacted by inflation is impacted by the net effect of nat cats. So there are many different elements that are impacting the risk premiums. So, overall we have planned for a rate injection across Europe that is still very strong in particular in a couple of geographies clearly where we had more natural catastrophe or where we see the market that has more need to push for price increase. For example, Germany, we are still pushing a lot. But overall I think the environment for price increase across Europe and across our geographies is still very strong.
Michael Huttner: Thank you.
Cristiano Borean: Yeah, third question, Michael. So extreme scenario in Taiwan implication of Solvency. It is a very in a certain sense difficult question, because we need to make inference of what would mean for the market. Let's work together on a reasoning, for example, of what could happen for the equity market. Clearly you have seen our equity sensitivities. Equity is down 25%, six percentage point of Solvency loss. That could be a reasonable scenario, knowing also that we have our business, which is devolving in China and we'll be being closer could be impacted with the Chinese equity being impacted more than the rest for example. For what regard the interest rate sensitivity? Clearly a scenario of war would create a scenario of deflation from the point of view of the potential interest rate movement, because of the so-called flight to quality. In this scenario you have noticed that our yield curve sensitivity for 50 bps all down in a parallel way brings basically three percentage point of Solvency. So even a higher level, it is much less than before. Last year it was a 25 percentage point for 50 bps. So this is clearly a scenario where you see coupled with also the sensitivity, which has been reduced massively in the last years on BTP spread bringing a company, which is less sensitive. And here comes the story of diversification of sources of cash flow, the balance and the reason why we updated you in the target operating range at the end of January. So I think it is a much more resilient group from what has been achieved so far.
Michael Huttner: Thanks. Super. Thanks so much.
Fabio Cleva: Next question please.
Operator: The next question is from Peter Eliot of Kepler Cheuvreux. Please go ahead.
Peter Eliot: Thank you very much. Mostly boring numbers questions, I'm afraid actually. The first one was on slide 18, the Life operating result. I was wondering Cristiano, if you could just take us through some of the moving parts there. I guess in particular, the loss component and the other items were a bit more negative than I was expecting. Obviously strong CSM release, et cetera, but some of the other items were very helpful to get your comments and guidance on? And then the second area was slide 66, very helpful on the discounting and unwinding. So, sorry, it's always the case when you give us some stuff we just want more. If I just try and understand that a bit, if I look on the left-hand side the discounting, if I multiply the claims reserves by duration by discount rate then for 2022, I get a much bigger discount than you're showing in €463 million. For 2023, I get much smaller than the €814 million. I think it's more, well, it is more than can be explained by just the rounding. So I'm just wondering why, I can't multiply those numbers together. And then the second thing on that was the duration. So the duration is falling as you've shown or it's lower in 2023. But if you look on the right-hand side then you're actually getting less from the most recent years than you showed us before. So I mean last time you had I think 56% coming from the two most recent years. Now we've got 48%. So just wondering if you could guide us on the duration and how that's changing and what we should expect going forward. And then the last one is very cheeky but great dividend. And so thank you for that. I guess we're in this weird position now where we've -- the current dividend guidance or policy has expired. And I guess we need to wait a year to get -- to find out what the dividend policy will be going forward. So the question is probably far too early, but just given that we're in sort of a little bit of limbo and given that some of your peers have given you policies, I'm just wondering if you've got any sort of thoughts that you want to share. Maybe too early, but now I'm trying. Thank you.
Fabio Cleva: Thank you, very much, Peter. Cristiano, the first and second question, are for you. Clearly, the second is quite technical. So in case Peter we can comeback to you after the call. And Philippe, the third question is for you.
Cristiano Borean: Yes, Peter. So, the first part, the moving part, I think that there are some specific also one-offs to be taken into account. There were one-off related to the external accepted reinsurance in our Group Employee Business, GEB, as well as some loss component stemming from accepted reinsurance business from external activity in Life, which was basically reviewed prudently downward from the data of experience, which has been provisioned, both in IFRS and in Local and it is creating this effect, which you should consider this as one-off, because it has been an adjustment of the trend and nothing else which we do see and think that can be repeated. On the second question, which is discounting versus unwinding? So, the discounting recalculation for sure, you should need to use the weight correctly. Those weights refer to the year-end '23, while the duration is a minor shift due to the pattern of the cash flow. I make an example. What is shifting, the structure of the cash flow from one year to the other was also the fact that in 2023 compared to 2022, we had much higher amount of natural catastrophes, which is by the way and I may anticipate a question, one of the reasons why you see a lower discounting compared to the third quarter, much lower when what you do only mathematically because you have less claims than in the third quarter because of the large natural catastrophe. So, these are reshaping the structure of the cash flow. So, on the part related to the part of the accident year versus the cash flow payments and the liability side. Okay? So, I think, this is basically all for the two parts, so I hand over to Philippe.
Philippe Donnet: Yes, talking about dividends, I remember then in 2016, when I was just appointed Group CEO, we paid an €0.80 dividend to shareholders. Since this year, the dividend has been constantly growing over the years. This year, as you have seen, we have accelerated the growth of the dividend paying €1.28, which is 60% higher than the €0.80 I was referring to. We've been implementing the ratchet during the past three years and by the way, we have achieved a cumulative dividend of €5.5 which is the upper range of the commitment we took at the beginning of the plan. On top of this, this year, we're going to anticipate with respect to the end of the plan €0.5 billion share buyback. So, I would say that, the dividend and capital management has been increasingly shareholders friendly in the past few years, thanks to our strong capital position, thanks to our strong cash and capital generation. And we have been building this over the past eight years. So it's definitely very solid and sustainable. So we are not going to disclose the next plan today. I'm afraid you will have to wait for the beginning of 2025. But definitely, I'm very confident that these shareholders friendly trend will continue during the next strategic plan.
Peter Eliot: Great. Thank you, very much. And IR has already very proactively followed up on -- I look forward to following up with them on that. Thank you.
Fabio Cleva: Thank you, Peter. Next question, please.
Operator: The next question is from William Hawkins (NASDAQ:HWKN) of KBW. Please go ahead.
William Hawkins: Hello. Thank you very much. Just two questions from me, please. Philippe, very much following on your previous comments, I am still a bit confused about your capital management priorities. Your January Investor Day seemed to indicate clearly that you feel your business mix repositioning is done. And in January, and I think on today's call, you're very much emphasizing dividends and share buybacks. And that's great. On the other hand, the risk of things are slightly flippant. There are many stories about M&A and Generali and quotes about financial strength being adequate for doing deals. And I'm just finding it difficult to put those two points together. So if you could help me. And on a tiny point of detail, I wasn't quite clear. In your prepared remarks, you made a reference to annual share buybacks. I'm not quite sure what you meant by that, please. So if you could clarify, that would be kind. And then to go to the other end of the spectrum, sorry to be a nerd, but on slide 46, Cristiano, very briefly, when we're looking at the non-operating items and particularly the market-related items that added up to 64, what's your view about what's normal for market-related items, please? I'm just trying to get a feel for big positive, big negative, small negligible, or whatever. Thank you very much.
Fabio Cleva: Thank you very much, William. Philippe, the first and second question are for you, while Cristiano, the third one, you will take that one.
Philippe Donnet: Well, I can only confirm what I have just said about capital management priorities, about dividends, about share buybacks. I mean, these are facts. We've been starting making share buybacks again, in Generali, because we stopped doing this for 15 years. We started doing this a couple of year's ago. Now, compared to what we said at the beginning, we will make -- before the end of the three-year plan, €0.5 billion share buyback. We are accelerating the growth of the dividends. In the past few years, we were able to do all of this together with €7 billion of M&A. And these are the facts. Then, I'm not going to comment any kind of press rumors, but what you have read in the press regarding M&A or targets, are only press rumors. Between press rumors and facts, you can easily make the choice. And then, yes, we are thinking to implement an even more efficient balance between M&A and capital management, which means that we will continue our activity on buyback programs, even on an annual basis, because this is the way to optimize value creation for shareholders.
Cristiano Borean: Hello, William. So third question on the non-operating investment result. Allow me to recall to you that that 64 number is not the number we use for the so-called adjusted net result, because you need to take out something of the order of €130 million of fair value to profit and loss to be negative, to be adjusted, in order to extract your final number. What happened in 2023? There were some, I would say, effects related to real estate cost impairment. You know that not all the real estate is a fair value, but still the part which is outside VFA at cost. And then some increased expected credit loss risk stemming from increased risk of credit in Asia and in Argentina for the situation. Overall, projecting in 2024, due to the fact that those numbers were also influenced by the capital gain in the Saxo and land we had for €216 million, which is something you cannot project, you should not project in 2024 something very particular. So this number being flat to around zero or something more is a right reasonable projection going forward.
William Hawkins: Thank you for the detail.
Fabio Cleva: Next question, please.
Operator: The next question is from Farooq Hanif of JPMorgan. Please go ahead.
Farooq Hanif: Hi everybody and good afternoon. Just to come back on M&A. I think the reason why Will and everybody is asking this question is that, the rumors say that you are about to look at every single insurance company in Europe as a potential target, but I think the message that we got from the Investor Day was, by making an annual decision on M&A versus buyback you're implying that M&A is still part of the plan potentially, but it's bolt on in nature. So I think that would be helpful if you could make some comment on that. I think just the size of M&A that you're looking for, I guess. The second question just going back to what you were saying about the Life insurance results, so more of a question for Cristiano. So if we take the non-operating -- sorry operating other income and losses and if we take the kind of the loss-making contracts, are you implying that both of those numbers should tend more towards zero, just wanted to get an idea of, the loss component and other operating income and expenses? And then, last question on pricing. So obviously the way that you show your average premium, it's the actual earned price on premiums on average, but what can you tell us about the actual pricing you're putting through on renewals? So for example, one of your competitors yesterday talked about double-digit price increasing in Germany. So just wanted to know, if you could give some comment on that? Thank you very much.
Fabio Cleva: Thank you very much Farooq, Philippe, the first question is for you. Cristiano, the second question is for you, while Marco the third question is for you.
Philippe Donnet: Okay. So I will try to say it, once more and I will try to be even more, clear, on this. We've been very active in the past few years with M&A, with share buybacks and with the acceleration of the growth of the dividends. Last year, we have been especially active on M&A with the acquisition of Liberty Seguros that we have closed a couple of months ago with the acquisition of Conning, which we will close early April this year. It's obvious, that exactly as we did for Cattolica generating an amazing extraction of synergies, because Cattolica was a great success in terms of integration and we will do exactly the same thing, being very much focused on the integration of Liberty Seguros and on the integration of Conning in order to extract the synergies, as it was expected and I would say even more than expected as we did with Cattolica. So I would say this is today's priority. This is today's focus of our management team. Then as I said in answering the previous question, there is a change, because before we said that, we would look at share buybacks at the end of the plan. There was an important evolution, because once again, we want to seek the most efficient balance between M&A activity and the buyback program even on an annual basis. This is what we've been doing this year. And we will continue doing this. And this is important. Then talking about M&A, the strategic framework we disclosed at the beginning of the plan has not changed. We look at M&A opportunities, if they have a great potential of value creation for shareholders and all stakeholders. Whatever the dimension is it's not about the size, it's about the potential value creation for all stakeholders. And we've been very disciplined, so far. We never went out of the strategic framework for M&A. It has not changed. And we will remain very, disciplined. We will consider opportunities only if there is a great financial, strategic, and cultural fit. If not, we will not consider them. And I can tell you that we've been very selective in the past eight years, and we'll continue being very selective.
Cristiano Borean: Yes, Farooq, so regarding Life Insurance results, loss making contracts, of course, we had both in 2022 and 2023 loss components broadly at the same level, but in 2023, also with some specific one-off, 2022 was also coming out from the movement on the rates and the evolution. Regarding going forward, 2024, this number would stay in the low to mid double-digit number expected next year. And the reason is that we have a reduced sensitivity to our loss component if we measure it around the interest rate movement. If I look at the other components, like other income and expected values, overall, basically, it is a high double-digit, if not triple-digit at the level of triple-digit. So overall, you are slightly above the triple-digit sum in the loss component of our income and experience variance, which are reduced and some having some effect, which we do not replicate as positive as in 2023, because we do not project the same level of market performance in 2023 going forward when we budgeted it.
Marco Sesana: Hi, Farooq. On your third question on price increases, so I would -- so when we say that we see price increases still strong, I clearly was referring to injected tariff increase that we planned for 2024. Clearly, that depends if we are talking about one geography or the other, and if you are talking about motor or non-motor, where clearly all of these, there is a difference for all of the segments. Probably, let me make a couple of examples and starting from the one you mentioned. So clearly, we are also seeing in Germany a double-digit price increase, especially when we talk about motor, less if we talk about non-motor, where we still enjoy, I think, good results with good development of risk premium, but still very high price increase. So focusing on motor, we also see a strong price increase. Same goes, for example, in Italy. Here, clearly, we had last year a difficult year in terms of nat cat, and so we are planning price increase both on motor, but also on non-motor, especially on SME, to make sure we can keep our development on risk premium. Across Europe, for example, I can mention also Spain will enjoy a good price increase in terms of injection. So overall, I do see an environment where we will push for rate injected in 2024 still at a high level.
Farooq Hanif: Thank you very much.
Fabio Cleva: Next question, please.
Operator: The next question is from Will Hardcastle of UBS. Please go ahead.
Will Hardcastle: Hi. Thanks for taking my question. The first one is just looking at the Q4 5% non-motor gross premium increases. How much of this was price via exposure? And I guess on non-motor, do you think you're tracking ahead of inflation here? It certainly seems like you are on motor. I'm just trying to get the non-motor specific. And anything at this stage you can provide in terms of attachment point changes on reinsurance purchasing? That would be helpful. Thanks.
Fabio Cleva: Thank you very much, Will. Both questions are for Marco.
Marco Sesana: Yes, so let me say, so yes, in non-motor in particular, we think we have done a good job in pushing for rate increase and developing a good profitability across all the different geographies. And we don't want to stop, so we will keep on pushing for additional price increase. Clearly, it's not only a matter, as I said, of inflation. There are many more elements that we see, and so we want to make sure that this is well priced in our book. I think the retention overall was a very good retention across all the different geographies. So overall our risk in force as we call them so are stable slightly growing -- so slightly growing. Clearly, if we take out of the picture Europe assistance that's a very good development which is -- clearly it's a different story. You know that we have a very good development mainly on the travel business for large contract and so that's a different story. But still I would say volumes are keeping up well even where we are pushing for a significant price increase. For example, we mentioned Germany and Italy before so on both geographies the risk in force are keeping up very well. On attachment point on reinsurance so as -- I think we have a reinsurance structure that is broadly in line with the one-off last year. For the cat program we increased our attachment point from 200 to 300 and our cat aggregate is broadly in line with the one we had last year. We switched from a different trigger so it's now deductible of around 25 million. But overall, I think, the structure of the reinsurance that we have in place is very similar to the one-off last year. Clearly, we had an effect on pricing, but capacity was there. So
Fabio Cleva: Perfect. Next question please.
Operator: The next question is from Steven Haywood of HSBC. Please go ahead.
Steven Haywood: Thank you. I have three questions please. You mentioned earlier in the call about strengthening European insurance operations and expanding global asset management. I just wanted to clarify whether this is what you have done and whether this is what you plan to do going forward as well. And then secondly, I see in your presentation that you highlight that you have a maximum of 12 billion debt capacity under Solvency II. But actually what is your capacity under either rating agency constraints or your own internal leverage constraints? Can you give us an idea of that as well? Thank you. And then thirdly, your real estate slide near the -- in the appendix you have a net vacancy rate of 4.3%. It excludes refurbs and vacancies that are up for sale. Can you give us an idea of what percentage of your book is under refurb or vacancy for sale as well? Is that possible? Thank you.
Fabio Cleva: Thank you very much, Steven. So the first question clearly is for you Philippe while the second Cristiano is for you and the third Marco is for you.
Philippe Donnet: Yes. With respect to 2024, what are we doing? Once again, we closed the Liberty Seguros acquisition a couple of months ago and we're going to close the Conning acquisition early April. After that once again we will be very much focused on the integration of both companies exactly as we have been doing with Cattolica, for example because this is a great way to create a lot of value. In Cattolica, the synergies are above the expectation because we've been very focused on this. If I take the example of Conning it's a very important opportunity for us to enhance our asset management culture and asset management capability building a global platform that was the rationale of the acquisition. I would say this is definitely the priority for 2024. We will present a new plan early 2025 and there will be a new guidance for M&A.
Cristiano Borean: Hello, Steven. So regarding the theoretical Solvency capacity clearly we always show this but we are very happy with the level of depth we achieved so far. By the way in this representation, which is the one favorite to add – which is related to the regulatory leverage and as well, if you just look within the new accounting standard, we end up being very low as a leverage ratio according to this standard. In any case yes, there is some potential movement of capacity without losing the rating but the structure of the depth we have so far, the maturity we are managing, the approach we want to have in being extremely disciplined around this is the major constraint and driver which is guiding us to stay where we are.
Marco Sesana: So on real estate, so I just want to point out that we work on the real estate constantly because we want to make sure we meet our ESG target. We want to refurbish the – all the different building for this. So overall, these amount to around 5% and yes, so probably another important point we still have 97% collection of rent, so overall as you can see I think we are doing – overall, we're doing well compared to what we see in the different reports in the market.
Steven Haywood: Thank you. The vacancy as well…
Fabio Cleva: Sorry. Steven, could you please repeat?
Steven Haywood: Yes, the vacancy for sale and proportion of your real estate portfolio was that including the 5%?
Marco Sesana: 5%, yes.
Steven Haywood: Okay. Thank you.
Fabio Cleva: Next question, please.
Operator: The next question is the last question from James Shuck of Citi.
James Shuck: Thank you very much and good morning, good afternoon. First question the OCG of €4.5 billion in full year 2023. Just interested in it's only €1 billion from P&C and I can see there's €2.9 billion of operating profit, €2.2 billion of EBIT. Could you just help me understand the difference between those two please? And if you did 22 points of capital generation in 2023, what's a normalized assumption going forward? Second question also on the debt capacity, but less to do with capacity and more to do with your plans. I think you've said that you'll keep the debt leverage kind of constant well, as in no net debt issuance under the current plan which runs the end of 2024. Post that and I appreciate I'm going into the next plan slightly, but are you looking at keeping the ratio of constants or would you look to keep the absolute level of debt constant? And then finally, just in terms of the Life flows, I think you mentioned, you expect to move to positive flows in Life in 2024. You also mentioned tactical changes on pricing, lower margins in the Italian products. I'm keen to just understand, what's going on with that product and how it stacks up in terms of competition against the Valore offering? Thank you very much.
Fabio Cleva: Thank you very much, James. I would say that all the three questions are for you Cristiano.
Cristiano Borean: So start with the first one, James. Operating capital generation in 2023. You were asking about the lower amount in Life. I think you all know that the capital generation is calculated against the Solvency II current year technical result, which is basically the one very close to the way you represent under IFRS 17, but on the current year where we were heavily affected by the natural catastrophes. So, the effect is a joint effect of €250 million €260 million of current year technical results and €750 million of discounting, unwinding and other effects. For what regards the guidance going forward, we still see a capability to go at this level of annual operating capital generation, which basically has already been achieved in 2023, what is -- as an run rate in 2024. So, for sure, we think that we can overachieve the target by more than 5% going forward, keeping this rate of growth. Second question related to the debt capacity. Basically, what I was saying is that, we are happy clearly, with the leverage that we have from the point of view of absolute level. There are some still Cattolica debt, which is inherited from that acquisition, which are at this stage to be considered because they are suboptimal also in the treatment for the potential Solvency II, which we will exploit further. In any case, this situation coupled with the growth of the tangible book because of the retained earnings net of the buyback as well, I think is giving us a lot of flexibility in how to manage any single year of renewal, knowing that the constraint for us is not to increase for any reason the -- for any specific business reason, the leverage, because clearly, we are happy with this amount, which is allowing us to save going forward something in the order, with the plan projected more than €60 million per year of gross saving. What about the third question? I think, it is for Marco.
Marco Sesana: Yes. Maybe, I can jump in here. So clearly, we are – so, as we described during the last year, we are changing the type of product that we have in our catalog. And yes, from time-to-time, when the debt -- the market debt is going to be in the market clearly, we are going to see an effect. But overall, the type of offering, the type of product that we are pushing now in the market, we believe is going to keep the inflow going for the next year, considering that we push really for protection. And this is a differentiating value that you cannot get in other type of offer and the mix of segregated fund unit-link. So, we do believe that for the type of segment that we are trying to target, these products are competitive, all-in-all putting together different needs, segregated fund unit-link and protection and keeping up also, with the return.
Fabio Cleva: Thank you very much Marco, and thanks everyone for dialing into the call. The Investor Relations team remains, at your disposal for any follow-up, and we wish you a happy afternoon. Goodbye.
Operator: Ladies and gentlemen, thank you for joining. The conference is now over. You may disconnect your telephones. Thank you.
This article was generated with the support of AI and reviewed by an editor. For more information see our T&C.