In May, core CPI printed at +0.29% and +0.25% on Median. But a lot of that, most of it, was core goods and the question was whether that month was a one-off due to be reversed at some point, or if shelter and other slower-moving things would come along.
Coming into this month, the economists’ consensus was for +0.21% on core; the inflation swap market trades headline inflation but actually implied something a tiny bit softer than the economists were expecting. We knew Used Cars was going to be weak again, but it seemed like people were all-in on the idea that the worm has turned and now inflation is going to head sharply lower.
Whether this turns out to be true or not, it’s important to realize that the reason economists think that is because unemployment is rising, indicating that we are either in or very near a recession, and economists think (against logic and data) that wages lead prices so this should herald a disinflationary pulse.
Now, I also think inflation is headed lower, but it’s because shelter is coming off the boil and not because the Fed successfully cracked the backs of labor.
So, what happened in June?
We saw a very weak headline number of -0.06%, which was mainly the fault of a very weak core inflation number of +0.06%. That’s the second quite weak core figure in a row. When median CPI comes out later today it should be even weaker than last month, at +0.195% or so. If we could repeat that median every month, it would be tantamount to inflation being at the Fed’s target because median normally tracks a little higher than core except when we are in an inflationary upswing.
But whereas last month’s inflation figure was all about core goods, this month we finally saw a bit of a deceleration in shelter. Okay, yes – core goods slipped further into deflation, because that category exists mainly to make me look stupid by going lower and lower when I keep thinking the disinflation must be nearly wrung out. Core Services dropped to 5.1% y/y from 5.3% y/y.
We had known Used Cars would be weak, and it was at -1.5% m/m. New cars also dragged. But I will say it again because I want to have the chance to appear stupid again next month: goods deflation is running its course.
Global shipping costs are rising again, the dollar will be vulnerable if the Fed begins to ease, and while used cars should continue to show large y/y declines for the next few months that’s mostly base effects. On an index level, the used cars price index is almost all the way back to the overall price level.
Since COVID, the general price level – what has happened to the average price of goods and services – is up 22.3%. Used Car prices are now only up 27.7%. Not all goods and services will move up exactly 22.3%; the point is that the dislocation in used cars is pretty much over and therefore we should expect at some point that used car inflation will start to look more like overall inflation.
But again, goods aren’t the story we really care about. The question is, what about services? The news here is all non-bad. (Some of it is good, some is just not bad.) This month, the story is that rents abruptly weakened on a m/m basis.
Primary Rents were +0.26% m/m (was +0.39% last month), and Owners’ Equivalent Rent was +0.28% (was +0.43% last month). This dropped the y/y rates to 5.07% and 5.45%, respectively.
That’s good news, but it is not unexpected news. The conundrum over the last 3-6 months has been why this wasn’t already happening. On a m/m basis, the rent numbers probably won’t get a lot better, but if they print around this level consistently then the y/y rent numbers will decelerate gradually.
Unfortunately, there is no sign of deflation in rents and they are likely to begin to reaccelerate later this year, or early next year. That is an out-of-consensus view, though, and you should keep in mind that the Fed believes we have imminent deflation in rents.
In addition to the softer rents numbers, Lodging Away from Home showed -2% m/m. However, like airfares (-5% m/m), LAFH is not something that is going to be a persistent large drag. It’s volatile. On airfares, this decline in prices matches nicely with the energy figures we saw yesterday that showed a surprising fall in jet fuel inventories. Prices dropped and people flew!
Moving on to “Supercore.” People made a lot last month of the m/m decline in core services ex-shelter, and they’ll make a lot of the fact that it declined m/m again this month. But that looks like a seasonal issue: last year the two softest months were also May and June. On a y/y basis, supercore showed another slight decline. Medical Care Services is 3.3% y/y, with Physicians’ and Hospital Services both holding pretty steady at a high level. I don’t see any major improvement in supercore yet.
Overall, there’s no doubting that this number is soothing for the Fed. It’s soothing for me too. Inflation is decelerating, and as I said last month I think the Fed will almost certainly deliver a token ease in the next couple of months.
The potential issue is that inflation isn’t slowing for the reason the Fed thinks it is. The economy is slowing, and unemployment is rising. I don’t know when Sahm first said it, but for decades I’ve been noting that when the Unemployment Rate rises at least 0.5% from its low, it always rises at least 1% more (here’s a time when I said it in 2011: https://inflationguy.blog/2011/07/10/no-mister-bond-i-expect-you-to-die/ ). Not that I’m bitter that it’s called the “Sahm Rule” now.
So yes, the economy is weakening and the labor market is softening. And that presages a deceleration in wage growth – or, really, a continuation in that deceleration. But the connection between wages and prices is loose at best, and that’s not why inflation will stay low, if it does.
In fact, I continue to believe that median inflation will end up settling in the high 3s, low 4s. There has always been an ‘unless’ clause to that belief, but it isn’t ‘unless we enter recession.’ We will enter into one, and probably already are, but recessions and decelerations in core inflation are also only a loose relationship at best. I
t isn’t the recession which is causing disinflation (after all, the disinflation started long before now). What may is the slow growth in the money supply, combined with the rebound in velocity eventually running its course. We are closer to the end of the velocity rebound than to the beginning, and while M2 is accelerating it isn’t problematic yet. Those are the nascent trends to watch closely.
In the meantime – the Fed has what it wants for now. Soft employment and softening inflation. An ease will follow shortly. Whether that is followed by further eases remains to be seen, but…for now…the trends are favorable for the central bank.