Empire State Realty Trust (NYSE:ESRT) showcased a strong performance in the second quarter of 2024, marked by sustained leasing momentum and observatory growth. The company reported its 10th consecutive quarter of lease percentage growth and positive mark-to-market lease spreads in New York City. ESRT's Manhattan office portfolio reached 93.3% occupancy, and the Empire State Building Observatory continued to be the top attraction globally.
The company has entered into agreements to acquire prime retail assets in Williamsburg, Brooklyn for $195 million, reflecting a strategic focus on New York City assets and capital recycling. With no significant debt maturities until December 2026 and the lowest leverage among New York City REITs, ESRT maintains a strong balance sheet. The company anticipates a core FFO of $66 million for Q2 and expects an FFO per share range of $0.90 to $0.94 for the full year.
Key Takeaways
- ESRT has achieved a 10th consecutive quarter of lease percentage growth.
- Manhattan office portfolio is now 93.3% leased.
- The Empire State Building Observatory named the top attraction worldwide for the third year.
- Agreements to acquire prime retail assets in Williamsburg, Brooklyn for $195 million.
- No significant debt maturities until December 2026, with the lowest leverage among peers.
- Core FFO reported at $66 million for Q2; full-year FFO per share expected to be $0.90 to $0.94.
Company Outlook
- ESRT is focusing on investment opportunities and distressed transactions.
- Expecting a 0-3% increase in same-store cash net operating income for the commercial portfolio.
- Anticipating an NOI of $94 million to $102 million for the Observatory business in 2024.
- Plans to refinance the mortgage on the Metro Center property and pay down maturing debt.
- Aiming to continue leasing momentum and maintain a healthy pipeline of leases in negotiation.
Bearish Highlights
- Higher interest rates on recent unsecured notes issuance may impact 2025.
- Observatory business affected by a shift in Easter to Q1 and a decrease in international travelers.
- A larger increase in G&A expenses is expected.
Bullish Highlights
- Strong leasing activity, with 640,000 square feet leased year-to-date.
- Positive outlook on the return to office for tech companies.
- Acquisition of retail assets expected to deliver high returns and boost stock performance.
- Proactive management of the rent roll is set to continue progress on lease percentage.
Misses
- Details on the second portfolio of Williamsburg retail assets not disclosed due to confidentiality.
Q&A Highlights
- ESRT sees solid growth in the Williamsburg retail corridor over the next 10 years.
- Net effective rents have increased by 10% in recent years.
- Office properties are currently experiencing the most distress.
- The company remains opportunistic and focused on delivering cash flow to the bottom line.
- Considering investing in its own stock through buybacks.
In the second quarter of 2024, Empire State Realty Trust (ESRT) has demonstrated robust financial health and strategic growth initiatives. With the continued success of its leasing activities and the acquisition of valuable retail assets, ESRT is well-positioned to capitalize on the vibrant New York City real estate market. The company's confidence in its FFO guidance and its proactive approach to managing its portfolio underscore its commitment to enhancing shareholder value and maintaining its leadership position in the industry. As ESRT continues to navigate the dynamic real estate landscape, its strategic investments and focus on sustainability and balance sheet management will be key drivers of its future success.
InvestingPro Insights
Empire State Realty Trust's (ESRT) second quarter of 2024 has been marked by strategic acquisitions and consistent leasing growth, and a deeper dive into the company's financial metrics provides further context for investors. According to InvestingPro data, ESRT has a market capitalization of $2.93 billion, indicating a substantial presence in the real estate market. Despite trading at a high earnings multiple with a P/E ratio of 35.03, the company's liquid assets surpass its short-term obligations, which could be a sign of financial resilience and stability.
InvestingPro Tips suggest that the company is trading at a low EBITDA valuation multiple, which could indicate that the company is potentially undervalued based on its earnings before interest, taxes, depreciation, and amortization. Additionally, ESRT's strong return over the last three months, with a 16% total price return, aligns with the company's positive performance narrative in the article.
For investors seeking a more in-depth analysis, InvestingPro offers additional tips on ESRT's financial health and growth prospects. By using the coupon code PRONEWS24, readers can get up to 10% off a yearly Pro and a yearly or biyearly Pro+ subscription, providing access to a comprehensive suite of tools and insights to make informed investment decisions. There are 7 additional InvestingPro Tips available, including predictions of profitability and recent performance highs, which can further guide investment strategies in the dynamic New York City real estate market.
Full transcript - Empire State Rty (ESRT) Q2 2024:
Operator: Greetings, and welcome to the Empire State Realty Trust Second Quarter 2024 Earnings Conference Call. At this time, all participants are in a listen-only mode. A brief question-and-answer session will follow the formal presentation. [Operator Instructions] As a reminder, this conference is being recorded. It is now my pleasure to introduce your host, Heather Houston, Senior Vice President, Chief Counsel, Corporate and Secretary. Thank you. You may begin.
Heather Houston: Good afternoon. Thank you for joining us today for Empire State Realty Trust's second quarter 2024 earnings conference call. In addition to the press release distributed yesterday, a quarterly supplemental package with further detail on our results and our latest investor presentation were posted in the Investors section of the Company's website at esrtreit.com. On today's call, management's prepared remarks and answers to your questions may contain forward-looking statements as defined in applicable securities laws, including those related to market conditions, property operations, capital expenditures, income expense, financial results and proposed transactions and events. As a reminder, forward-looking statements represent management's current estimates. They are subject to risks and uncertainties, which may cause actual results to differ from those discussed today. Empire State Realty Trust assumes no obligation to update any forward-looking statements in the future. We encourage listeners to review the more detailed discussions related to these forward-looking statements in the Company's filings with the SEC. During today's call, we will discuss certain non-GAAP financial measures such as FFO, modified and core FFO, NOI, same store property cash NOI, EBITDA and adjusted EBITDA, which we believe are meaningful in evaluating the Company's performance. The definitions and reconciliations of these measures to the most directly comparable GAAP measures are included in the earnings release and supplemental package, each available on the Company's website. Now, I will turn the call over to Tony Malkin, our Chairman and Chief Executive Officer.
Tony Malkin: Thanks, Heather. And good afternoon to everyone. Yesterday, we reported ESRT's strong second quarter year-to-date results. We are happy to report continued strong leasing momentum, observatory growth and capital recycling progress. So, let's dive into our discussion of our results for 2Q and our outlook for the rest of 2024. In the Q2, we delivered once again on office leasing absorption and positive rent spreads. Here's the big leasing story for New York City office. Team ESRT put points on the board again with our 10th consecutive quarter of least percentage growth, that's 10 quarters in a row and our 12th consecutive quarter of positive New York City mark to market lease spreads. Positive lease absorption, positive lease spreads, New York City is strong and our modernized, amenitized energy efficient properties with indoor environmental quality are in demand. Our Observatory performance continues very nicely and was named number one destination attraction in the United States for the third consecutive year and number one destination attraction in the world for the first time and TripAdvisor (NASDAQ:TRIP)'s best of the best. We have contracted to expand the retail component of our NOI with additional retail on the Prime North 6th submarket of the remarkable Williamsburg submarket of Brooklyn. And we maintain a best-in-class balance sheet. In 2024, ESRT is on our front foot and we are eager to create additional value for our shareholders in the current real estate cycle. Year-to-date, we have leased 640,000 square feet, of which 270,000 square feet were leased in the second quarter. Our Manhattan office portfolio had 170 basis points of positive leased absorption year over year and is now 93.3% leased. Our redevelopment work over the past decade has produced a unique top of tier product that tenants want to lease. Please see a new slide on Page 9 of our investor deck that features great before and after pictures. ESRT's commitment to service and tenant relationships continue to drive strong tenant retention and expansion within our portfolio over time. Since our IPO and this is a new number that just continues to grow. We have seen 2.8 million square feet of new leases comprised of tenant expansions. Tenants appreciate that we have the lowest leverage of any New York City REIT, a strong liquidity position and have addressed all meaningful debt maturities until December 2026. Our balance sheet delivers leases. Year-to-date, Observatory NOI is up 6% year-over-year, driven by continued improvement in revenue per caps and increase in visitation. Our NOI per cap towers above the competition. Our global brand awareness has no equal. And as noted, in June, the Empire State Building deck was Observatory Deck was named the number one attraction in the world and TripAdvisor's 2024 Travelers (NYSE:TRV) Choice Awards, Best Things to Do, and the number one attraction in the United States for the third consecutive year. I promised our Observatory team I would take a pie in the face if we achieved this great result and watch our social channels for that very occurrence soon. See Slide 17 of our investor presentation for more on the Observatory performance story. Sustainability continues to be a cornerstone of ESRT's business philosophy. And we are the leader in environmental stewardship and healthy building performance. Just last week, the Empire State Building earned the Building and Owners Management Association, OMA, 2024 International Earth Award. That is a big deal and we are so happy for the recognition of our team. Please read our 2023 Sustainability Report to see what leadership looks like. Our track record of successful sustainability partnerships with companies and their employees attracts tenants and contributes to our leasing success. Tom, Christina and Steve will provide more detail on our progress and how we plan to accomplish these goals in the balance of 2024. Now I'd like to hand it over to Tom.
Tom Durels: Hey, thanks, Tony, and good afternoon, everyone. In the second quarter, our office and retail portfolio continued its steady trajectory of positive absorption. This was the 10th consecutive quarter in which our team increased our lease percentage, that's an increase of 690 basis points since the fourth quarter of 2021. Today, our Manhattan office portfolio stands at 93.3% leased, an increase of 60 basis points compared to last quarter and is up 170 basis points compared to a year ago. In the second quarter, our Manhattan office increased by 120 basis points year-over-year to 88.8%. The second quarter was also our 12th straight quarter with positive mark to market lease spreads in our Manhattan office portfolio. New and renewal leases were signed with positive mark to market rent spreads of 2%. Leasing volumes continue to be strong with 272,000 square feet of total leasing in the second quarter, inclusive of 55,000 square feet of early renewals. This increases the total lease assigned year-to-date to 642,000 square feet. We have added new disclosure in our supplemental on pages 11 to 12 to include early renewals, defined as leases that are renewed two or more years ahead of lease expiration. Nearly all the early renewals signed year-to-date were done in connection with expansions. While it has always been our practice to seek opportunity to extend the lease term of existing tenants, we did not previously include these numbers in our reported renewal statistics. Notable office leases signed during the second quarter include an 11-year 41,000 square foot expansion lease with Pontera Solutions, who relocate to the Empire State Building from the current 11,000 square foot space at 111 West 33rd Street. An 11-year 28,000 square foot new lease on the two highest office floors at the Empire State Building with global management consulting firm Kearney and an 11-year 25,000 square foot new lease with The William Carter Company at 1350 Broadway. An 11-year 12,000 square foot expansion lease at one Grand Star took place, and we signed leases for 17 prebuilt office suites that total 87,000 square feet. At the Empire State Building and One Grand Central Place, we have increased asking rents in response to strong demand. Additionally, we have begun to reduce the amount of free rent offered in proposals on deals throughout the portfolio. As shown on Page 10 of our supplemental, we have $42 million in an incremental cash revenue from signed leases not commenced and a frequent burn off. And just this morning, we received a signed lease from a tech firm for a full floor of 24,000 square feet at 1350 Broadway. Our leasing results demonstrate that our fully modernized buildings located in Midtown with access to mass transit, quality amenities, strong balance sheet, great service, best in class indoor environmental quality and sustainability and an accessible price point continue to attract quality tenants. ESRT offers top of tier product in our price bracket and our portfolio offers what tenants wants. You've heard us talk about the $1 billion spent to fully modernize and amenitized our portfolio. And please make sure to check out our new slide on Page 9 in the investor presentation with before and after pictures to help visualize just how meaningful portfolio transformation has been. It is because of this redevelopment work over the past decade, carried out by our exceptional leaders, Ryan Kass in Leasing, Mike Prunty in Property Management, Dana Schneider in Sustainability, and Pete Sjolund in Construction, that we have top of tier assets today that attract leasing demand and win in the flight to quality. In addition to the previously mentioned 24,000 square foot lease that was signed today, we have a healthy pipeline of another 150,000 square feet of leases in negotiation, of which 70,000 square feet are new deals and the balance are renewals. In our Manhattan office portfolio, we have modest lease expiration for the balance of 2024 with 190,000 square feet of known vacates and 12,000 square feet is undecided at this time. Looking forward to 2025, we have only 162,000 square feet of known vacates and 114,000 square feet of tenants who are undecided. This is against the backdrop of an average 827,000 square feet of annual leasing for the past three years in our Manhattan office portfolio. Our multifamily portfolio with occupancy of 97.9% at quarter end continues to perform exceptionally well and benefit from strong market fundamentals and recent property improvements. In summary, in the second quarter, we signed over 272,000 square feet of commercial leases. We increased our Manhattan office leased percentage by 170 basis points from a year ago to 93.3%. We had our 10th consecutive quarter of increased leased percentage. Our Manhattan office occupancy increased by 120 basis points compared to last year to 88.8%. We have a healthy pipeline of activity and we continue to have strong performance in our multifamily portfolio. With that, thank you. I will now turn the call over to Christina.
Christina Chiu: Thanks, Tom. We continue to make progress with our capital recycling initiatives. As disclosed in our earnings release, subsequent to quarter end, we entered into two agreements to acquire Prime Retail Assets in Williamsburg, Brooklyn for $195 million in aggregate with anticipated closing dates in 3Q. The first portfolio is for $103 million of assets located on North 6th Street between Wythe and Berry Street. These assets span approximately 40,000 square feet across five retail storefronts that include high quality tenants such as [Indiscernible]. These assets are 86% leased with near term upside from signed leases that have not yet commenced in addition to vacancy lease up. The in-place retailers have a weighted average lease term of 7.5 years and we estimate significant mark-to-market upside as leases roll. The second portfolio is for $92 million of prime retail assets also on North 6th Street. Due to confidentiality requirements, more details on this additional portfolio will be disclosed upon closing. We are very pleased to increase our scale in this prime retail corridor of Williamsburg following our prior acquisition of a retail asset on North 6th Street in September 2023 that continues to benefit from increasing population density, strong household income and new multifamily and hospitality development recently completed and underway. We see the Williamsburg story to be a decade ahead of value creation. Please see Slides 19 to 20 for more color on these transactions and the strength of this retail submarket. These all-cash acquisitions are consistent with our strategy over the past couple of years to recycle capital and balance sheet capacity from non-core suburban assets into strong New York City assets. As shown in a new Slide 10 in our investor deck, we have disposed of five non-core assets in Westchester and Connecticut since 2022 and recycled into nearly $650 million of high-quality New York City multifamily and retail assets that have great growth prospects and less capital expenditure requirements over time. As a result of this capital recycling, we have improved our sector diversification. Pro forma a for the latest retail and the previously announced disposition of suburban office, our NOI composition is approximately 58% office, 12% retail, 5% multifamily, and 25% Observatory. Importantly, we strategically executed on these capital recycling transactions, while maintaining our peer leading balance sheet strength and below average leverage. Going forward, we will continue to focus on investment opportunities with attractive upside potential in addition to distressed transactions that we expect to arrive in this cycle. In July, we executed an agreement to refinance the mortgage on our Metro Center property that was due to mature in November 2024. Beginning November 2024, the new loan balance of $72 million will be interest only at the same interest rate of 3.6%, with a maturity of November 2029 inclusive of a one-year extension option. As previously mentioned, we intend to use a portion of the proceeds from our recent unsecured notes issuance to pay down the $100 million maturity in March 2025. As a result, we have no meaningful uncovered debt maturity to address until December 2026 when a $175 million term loan matures. At quarter end, the Company had $2.3 billion of total debt outstanding with a weighted average interest rate of 4.27% and a weighted average term to maturity of 5.8 years pro form a for the recent Metro Center refinancing and the planned pay down of our March 2025 debt maturity. We have strong liquidity, no floating rate debt exposure, a well laddered debt maturity schedule and the lowest leverage among all New York City focused REITs at 5.1 times net debt to EBITDA. Please note that we do expect leverage to tick up from this level once the Williamsburg acquisitions are closed and after we utilize cash from the recent unsecured notes offering to pay down maturing debt in March 2025. As we have said for many years, we are prepared to increase leverage to take advantage of value opportunities to grow our business. We view approximately 6 times net debt to EBITDA as a more stabilized leverage level to think about going forward. And now, I will turn the call over to Steve to discuss our results and outlook for the remainder of 2024. Steve?
Steve Horn: Thanks, Christina. For the Q2 of 2024, we reported core FFO of $66 million or $0.24 per diluted share. Same store property cash NOI increased 7.4% year-over-year, primarily driven by higher revenues from cash rent commencement, which was partially offset by increases in property operating expenses, which we anticipate in our guidance, albeit the increase was less than initially guided, partially due to lighter utility expenses than expected. Note that the second quarter also included approximately $2 million of positive onetime revenue items. Excluding these nonrecurring items from the current period and prior year period, second quarter adjusted same store cash NOI increased by approximately 6% year-over-year. Moving to our Observatory business. We generated net operating income of $25 million in the second quarter, approximately 2% higher than the prior year period. Observatory expense was $8.9 million in the second quarter. Keep in mind that the shift of the Easter holiday into the first quarter of this year versus the second quarter of last year impacts comparability. Year-to-date, net operating income for the Observatory was $41 million an increase of approximately 6% year-over-year. Revenue per capita remains high and year to date admissions continue to improve year-over-year. Now on to our outlook for 2024. We continue to expect 2024 FFO to range between $0.90 $0.94 per fully diluted share. Within this range, our key assumptions are as follows, same store cash net operating income for the commercial portfolio to range from zero to 3% relative to 2023 levels. This represents a 100 basis point increase from our original expected range. The increase is largely driven by our expectation for property operating expenses and real estate taxes to come in towards the lower end of our previous range of a 6% to 8% increase over the prior year. We now expect an approximate 6% to 7% increase year-over-year. The improvement is primarily due to lighter than expected utility and payroll expenses. Within this range, we continue to expect positive revenue growth, which assumes commercial occupancy of 87% to 89% by year end 2024, driven by a strong pipeline of signed leases not yet commenced and manageable lease expirations in 2024. We continue to expect 2024 Observatory NOI to be approximately $94 million to $102 million and average Observatory expenses of approximately $9 million per quarter. Our guidance range takes into account variability in our Observatory results due to tourism fluctuations and bad weather in any given quarter and the recent capital markets and transaction activity announced year-to-date. Also included within our FFO guidance range, we expect a larger than usual increase in 2024 G&A to approximately $68 million for the full year to reflect the recent annual promotions and accelerated recognition of certain non-cash stock-based compensation expense as a result of executives approaching retirement eligibility. While we do not provide our formal outlook for 2025 yet, we do believe it is important to share a few items that could impact next year. Those include; one, the full year run rate of higher G&A as just discussed; and two, the nine-month impact of the higher interest rate on our recent unsecured notes issuance. With that, I will now turn the call back to the operator for the Q&A session. Operator?
Operator: Thank you. We will now be conducting a question-and-answer session. [Operator Instructions] Our first question comes from the line of Steve Sakwa with Evercore. Please proceed with your question.
Steve Sakwa: Maybe starting on the just the pipeline, Tom, and sort of the leasing activity that you're seeing. Just any additional thoughts and color that you can provide around kind of expansion opportunities and just kind of the discussions that you're having with tenants. And I noticed that you had that new disclosure about early renewals. Is that something that you're hearing and seeing more of today and tenants willing to come to you early, maybe sooner than they have to kind of lock in space today?
Tom Durels: I'll take the second part of your question first, Steve. We have always executed on early renewals and certainly we make that part of our discussion with existing tenants. Often it comes in connection with an expansion of an existing tenant where we look to use that opportunity to extend their existing lease on the back of their current term. And so, that's always been kind of our part of our diet. And so that we see that really more the case. As far as pipeline, we've got look, as I mentioned before, we just received a signed lease for a full floor of 24,000 square feet at 1350 Broadway, between that and the deal we signed with Carter's (NYSE:CRI), it's going to bring that building into the mid-90% leased. We've got another, call it, 160,000 square feet of leases in negotiation, 150,000 of that is in Manhattan for office portfolio. And we're look, we've been approached by a tenant at the Empire State Building for an expansion. We haven't yet issued paper on that, but they're talking to us about taking an additional full floor. So, what we're seeing more often is that more and more tenants have moved beyond this whole issue of work from home. They're committing to their space in New York City. They want desks for their employees. Their employees want to be in the office and you're seeing more and more of that decisiveness by tenants and that's reflected in look the attractive leasing results we've had to date and the good pipeline we're seeing now.
Tony Malkin: And the only thing I'd add to that, Steve, Tony Malkin here is that people come to us, brokers come to us, we are on the list because we're I'm not just pushing our own book here. They come for the modernization, amenitization, the energy efficiency, the IEQ, they look at that and say these are key attractants for their employees. The brokers come to us because of our balance sheet and they know that there is no issue of speaking with us and the lender, that we can do the whole transaction ourselves and take care of everything based on our reputation. And the existing tenants are huge advocates for us. We see it we see now a lot of new tenants come to us on the basis of recommendation of current tenants. So, we are in a different zone. New York City, in general, is recovering. We are not recovering. We are forward.
Steve Sakwa: Okay, great. And then second question, Christine, I know you can't provide maybe tons of detail on the retail transactions, but maybe on the bigger one. Can you kind of provide anything about going in yields and maybe where you think that portfolio might stabilize a couple of years out? How do you think about the NOI growth on that portfolio over the next maybe two, three, four years?
Christina Chiu: Sure. So, we will definitely provide more details at closing. Just given confidentiality agreements, we're not closed yet. We can't provide that much more at this time. What I can say as a reference point, which should be helpful is our acquisition last year of Prime Retail in Williamsburg was just under a 6% for a stabilized asset with no near-term CapEx and strong upside over time. As we alluded to both in my remarks and in our investor deck for these acquisitions, these are prime retail assets with some near-term ramp up from signed leases not yet commenced and vacancy lease up, plus has characteristics of long-term upside that we believe will create a lot of value over time. So hopefully that's helpful in the landscape.
Tony Malkin: I would add to that, Tony, again. If you look at this, this won't repeat SoHo meatpacking, but it's going to rhyme with SoHo meatpacking. And we think there's a solid 10-year run of growth in what will happen here in this remarkable submarket. So, we're really pleased to have been able to transact, and we’ve given you more detail than we gave on the residential acquisitions and hopefully that is better for you guys.
Operator: Our next question comes from the line of John Kim with BMO Capital Markets. Please proceed with your question.
John Kim: Thank you. Just a follow-up on the retail acquisition. I was wondering if you could provide where you think market rents are for Williamsburg on that corridor and where you think it could go to? I mean, if we're looking at CoStar data, it would suggest the cap rate or initial cap rate around 2%, which seems pretty low. I don't know if that data is accurate, but just wanted some color on market rents.
Tom Durels: Look, as Christina said, right, we're bound by confidentiality. In general, the location is fantastic. Two prime blocks on North 6th Street is where these properties are located. You can look at various market data out there where deals are getting done well north of $300 a foot. And I think at this point that's we'll have more to disclose after closing specific to our transaction.
Tony Malkin: Combined with the characteristics here that these are this property type is one with which we've had a lot of familiarity, particularly going into developing neighborhoods historically, 10 Union Square as a prime example of that. And the fact is that these will produce a heck of a lot of cash flow out of their NOI. And that's what attracts us to this asset category and we again, we see tremendous growth here in this market area.
John Kim: Okay. My second question is on the new disclosure you had on the lead renewals. So it looks like because of the early renewal disclosure, your first quarter leasing activity picked up as you include the 122,000 square feet of early renewals. My question is, where did you disclose that before? Was that as the leases commenced, that number was then, so you're just basically pulling forward that leasing activity or was it just not previously disclosed?
Tom Durels: Well, first of all -- John, yes, first of all, it was excluded from our reported leasing statistics on transactions, however, where it would appear is simply in the annual lease expirations. So as leases get pushed out, that would simply show up in the rollover schedule that appears in our supplemental. But we thought it was helpful to give the additional color on these early renewals defined as lease extensions done, where there's more than two years of remaining lease term left.
John Kim: Okay. I mean, I'm just when I look at the first quarter, this disclosed this quarter and last quarter activity picked up and then the lease spreads also moved a little bit. So again, I'm a little bit confused as to whether or not you're just pulling this up and previously that was disclosed when those leases commence. But I'm happy to take this offline.
Tom Durels: Sure. I'm not sure. Happy to spend more time with you afterwards. But I think the separate disclosure on the leasing on the early renewals is pretty straightforward.
Operator: Our next question comes from the line of Michael Griffin with Citi. Please proceed with your question.
Michael Griffin: Maybe just getting back to kind of the forward outlook and leasing pipeline. Tom, I think in your prepared remarks, you mentioned, I think, free rent starting to stabilize and go down. But have you seen really a change on other concessions, whether it's tenant improvements or other things? And then, can you give us a sense of kind of how net effective rents have been trending?
Tom Durels: So, I'm glad you asked that question, because I was expecting some questions on our leasing costs, which one might read into that they went up slightly this quarter. But on a year-to-date average, they're really very much in line with 2023. But if you look at our net effective rents over the last 3 years, 2.5 to 3 years, we're up about 10% from 2021 on an average for year-to-date. And so, I think that's a pretty healthy indicator. Look, we focus on net effect of rent because it factors in all of the lease economics, not just the leasing cost, but certainly the top line rent. The deals that we did with Kearney and Pontera, they're going to average over $80 a square foot during the term of their lease. And so generally, look, we're moving in the right direction. I'm heartened by the fact that we're tightening up on our free rent offering. We still deliver turnkey build space. We have a lot of pre-built product that's already built in second generation, keeping our leasing cost down. And our full floor deals will deliver turnkey space for tenants because they look to us to design and build the space for them, so that they can focus on their business. And we execute on what we do best.
Tony Malkin: And I would add to that, where we do see movement right now is in our rents and in our free rent. And you'll see the effects of that as we report in the future with greater definition, number one. Number two, what really helps distinguish us amongst other landlords is we have an integrated team of architecture, completely qualified construction team led by Pete Sjolund and the sustainability piece. And our ability to turnkey for people high performing spaces with indoor environmental quality is a huge attractant. So, the fact that people of all tenants of all sizes, very few tenants who come to us build up their own space. It's an added feature and benefit to a transaction with ESRT.
Michael Griffin: Great. Appreciate the additional color there, Tony. And then just on sort of distressed opportunities that you're seeing out in the market. I mean, it seems like the Williamsburg acquisition might have been more stabilized, maybe not as much hair on that. But for other things that you're seeing out there, I mean, are we seeing the distress more in one property type? Is it, office that is providing maybe more attractive returns? Or do you still see opportunities within retail and multifamily in order to benefit from some of the stress out there?
Tony Malkin: So, I would tell you that in multifamily, because of the GSEs, the Freddie Fannie and the popularity there, the real issue there is that if you have a low interest rate, your equity is significantly hit or could evaporate due to a refi. We don't really qualify them as distressed because we see a lot of attention there. We did do a very good purchase at 298 Mulberry. I don't think that anybody thought that was distressed. We just got in there and we found ways to create a lot of value. We do see opportunities developing in that area based on property handovers. We see a lot of attention from buyers. With regard to the retail we purchased, you're correct. We look at that and say, we think we paid a fair price to a willing seller. And just over time, with our duration, we see a great opportunity for synergy of what we've already bought. And we really understand feet on the ground how to work on that. We do see the biggest distress in office. There's no question. And a lot of the office distress out there, it's all a matter of basis. And we've got to get to the right basis where we can attract capital to partner with us to acquire property. And we really think that the pricing needs to be able to deliver a 3x multiple of invested capital over a 7- to 10-year time frame in order to attract capital to partner with our balance sheet to do those transactions. We do not see either the property types by location, floor plate, we've seen one office property on which we bid. And JPMorgan Chase (NYSE:JPM) has contracted to acquire it because it's next to their new headquarters. And outside of that, we're biding our time. We're waiting for the right pricing. With that in mind, I think on the overall perspective, you have to focus on the number of transactions and dollar volume of transactions are tremendously down and remain tremendously down. We do see more properties coming to the market. And the other area where I think we might see distress coming in the future also though it's a submarket is this medical research, biotech purpose-built lab space, where there's just not as much demand and there's been a lot of products put out there. But I don't think that's something we will pursue. Tom or Christine, anything you want to add to that, color on the market?
Tom Durels: No.
Michael Griffin: Thanks.
Operator: I’m sorry. Please proceed with your question. Mr. Griffin?
Michael Griffin: Yes, I had just finished my questions. Thank you.
Operator: Thank you. Our next question comes from the line from Blaine Heck with Wells Fargo. Please proceed with your question.
Blaine Heck: Great. Thanks. Good afternoon. Just following up on the acquisitions, can you talk a little bit more about how the transactions were sourced? Were they off market or marketed deals? And also, whether you think the NOI mix that Christina went over is optimal for your portfolio? Or should we expect the non-office exposure to kind of continue to grow?
Tony Malkin: So, there's a universal shaking our heads of no around the table. We really don't want to comment on the sourcing. We'll just say that we work hard on this stuff and we want to respect our partners on the other side of this transaction. So we really don't have anything to say there. And as far as the mix, look, we remain, as we've said over time, we're omnivorous opportunivores. And we really we like how our NOI mix is it will develop. We think that this initial acquisition has a starting point, but then we'll have greater value over time as a component of our NOI mix. And in the meantime, though, we've got other things, which are also developing very well as far as NOI on the resi and on the office side. So, I do think a thing that is of interest to us is when we come to NOI and FFO, what's really hitting the bottom line in the form of cash. And we've mentioned this in the prior earnings call and that's really our focus. Everything we do, lease space, sell tickets, deliver on our sustainability objectives, manage the balance sheet, flow cash to the bottom line, so that we have greater flexibility as we go forward. And so we really will remain opportunistic. We've got a lot of areas where we can deploy capital with confidence when we see the right opportunity.
Blaine Heck: Great. Thanks, Tony. And just following up on that, I guess, how did you guys weigh this purchase of retail assets versus investing more in your own stock through repurchases at potentially higher returns at this point?
Tony Malkin: We definitely look at this as something with duration will deliver a very high return to us relative to where we think a purchase of our stock we think it will greatly help our stock as we go forward. And we just think there's tremendous upside, if you have duration here. And so we do have duration and we can live through a couple of lease cycles on this. I don't know, Christina, Tom, Christina comment?
Christina Chiu: I would just say we have buybacks on the agenda. We've done it in size. It remains a strategic part of capital allocation. And as we mentioned earlier, unique opportunity to create scale on a very prime retail corridor in a great location, high foot traffic in Manhattan high demographics. We've mentioned this market also has more opportunity for retail, more opportunity for residential, create long-term upside over time and in an asset class that has a different CapEx profiles versus office. So for a lot of reasons and this made a lot of sense. So fortunately, we have a great balance sheet. Nothing is off the table. We'll evaluate everything but this was a really unique and great opportunity for the Company.
Blaine Heck: Great. That's very helpful. And then it seems as though optimism around the return to office or tech companies has been building, layoff has come through, and some of the companies are mandating more in person office time. Tom, great to hear about the lease this morning, and you guys have additional tech exposure in your portfolio. So, can you just talk about expectations with respect to leasing activity amongst tech tenants and whether you're seeing kind of any shift in their preference to be in New York versus their more traditional footprint on the West Coast?
Tom Durels: Well, I'll give you two examples. The lease that we just signed at 1350 Broadway for full floor of 24,000 square feet, that's a tech firm. And that represents growth by the expansion by them. The other tenant I mentioned that's looking to expand at Empire State Building during COVID. They had given us shed some space elsewhere outside of our building. Now looking back and saying, we want our employees in the office and they want to be in the office. And they all deserve to have desks, and they want to have desks. And so they're looking at an expansion with us by a fairly significant amount, more than doubling their size. So those are two very good examples of what we're seeing in the tech space. And look, as you know, our rent role is very diversified. We're not focused on one single industry. We attract tenants from all industry and the examples I give and the commentary I just gave about that potential expansion tenant in Empire State, but we're hearing that more and more from other tenants there. The fog or the indecisiveness around the work from home, they've moved beyond that. They're making clear plans, definitive plans to place their office and have their employees in the office in New York City.
Tony Malkin: And I'll also add two things. I want to be careful on this use of the term tech firm. Both of these companies of which Tom just spoke are highly profitable. They are not startups. They've got very good business models. And so we do, as you know, a real underwriting of these businesses and their viability before we sign a tenant. Our largest tenant, LinkedIn, started as a single floor at the Empire State Building. That was a time when everyone thought they were just another tech startup, and we did the research. We said, no, no, this is a real business with real business growth prospects. So let's be careful. We have not changed our underwriting standards one bit. Number two, New York City is absolutely positively destination for new tech jobs. It's because that's where the employees, the colleagues, the team members want to be. That is a statistic. New York City is alive. It is vigorous. I was in San Francisco on Tuesday and Thursday -- Tuesday Wednesday, excuse me, of last week. There is simply no comparison between the two markets. New York City is popping and the energy is tremendously attractive, not just to recent college grads, but also to people who want to move and locate where there is going to be activity and there's going to be life. As our lead director says, it's where people want to create their lives, meet their future life partners and enjoy life. And the last thing that I'll say is with regard to this is we see a tremendous interest in us by virtue of tenants' responses to their employees and colleagues' attendance in the office in our buildings. And the tenant who looks to expand at the Empire State Building, they had looked to shed other office spaces. At the same time, they saw the number one location for employee in office participation out of their locations was the Empire State Building. And they said, okay, we want more space there because that's where people show up. So I think that just to round it out. I want to make sure from a balance sheet perspective, I understand we're not taking additional risk. New York City is definitely the desired location. And our portfolio particularly is attractive on the basis of existing tenants' experiences with our own employees and colleagues.
Blaine Heck: Very helpful. Thanks, everyone.
Operator: Our next question comes from the line of Camille Bonnel with Bank of America. Please proceed with your question.
Camille Bonnel: Hi, Tom. I wanted to follow-up on your comments around leasing costs being lower because of the strategy you've implemented this year. So looking forward, as you work through leasing these turnkey spaces, I wanted to get a better sense of what's going on in the general market given there are reports that tenant improvements are increasing in Manhattan? Are you seeing these trends too in the portion of the market that you operate in, or is this less of a concern because there's enough demand to continue implementing that turnkey solution?
Tom Durels: Camille, I would say this. As I mentioned earlier, our average net effective rent has increased by 10% over the past three years, and that factors in the top line gross rents as well as the leasing costs and that's the number to really keep an eye on. As I mentioned earlier, and as Tony mentioned, we're moving our rents, we're tightening up on free rent and that's having an impact on improving our net effective rents. We benefit from having built space throughout our portfolio. As I mentioned earlier, we have an inventory of second generation pre-built space that is less expensive to turn it back into service for a new tenant and that helps lower our TI costs, having previously already invested the capital in those spaces. And then generally nothing has changed over the last five to six years in terms of what we deliver to tenants by way of full turnkey service. It's always been part of our offering. We deliver pre-built space ready for move in and we deliver turnkey spaces, we're talking to a tenant for a large full floor space for a long-term, we would just custom design and build that space for that tenant. So, what we're offering on TI has been pretty consistent, we're benefiting from again having invested capital previously. But all in all, our net effective rent has improved 10% over the past three years. So hopefully that gives better perspective and answer to your question.
Camille Bonnel: Got it. And shifting to your Observatory business, it continues to show good growth. So, what do you attribute to the lower visitor count versus last year despite having less bad weather days?
Tony Malkin: Tony here. First of all, we did have a shift of Easter into the first quarter of this year and that always produces a shift. So, and last year's comp, Easter was in the second quarter, number one. Number two, we're managing the demand in order to maximize the benefit to the visitor. And we do see that we have from time to time, we cap our attendance. But the biggest shift is from Easter. That's the first piece. I will say there's one other piece and that is that there's unquestionably a much lower international traveler presence in New York City this summer, full stop. You can get it from the airlines. Even the New York City Official Travel Bureau will grudgingly acknowledge this. When you look at established venues from the 911 Museum on across New York, Statue of Liberty, you name it, everyone has recognized and commented on this. And so, what we see is big domestic demand, which comes with domestic travel pieces. The international demand is not as robust. It is still gathering back strength. And yet what I would draw attention to is we've continued to grow the top-line, we've continued to grow the bottom line and our NOI per cap continues to tower above any other competitor. So, we feel very good about where we are and about what we're doing with our business there.
Camille Bonnel: That color is very helpful. And just finally, despite perceptions on how to define quality, your leasing teams continue to define a norm. So, I'm curious to get your views on where you see structural vacancy for your office portfolio. Do you expect to be able to grow your lease percent much further above the 92%, 93% levels today?
Tom Durels: Camille, we're really well positioned based on all the work that we've done. For the balance of the year, we have about 190,000 square feet of tenant vacates. And the space that we're getting back are full floors, they're consolidated, they're very marketable, some come with outdoor terrace space. So, we're confident that we will be able to lease those spaces. And so that's a modest amount of lease expirations and tenant vacates, and offset by the leasing activity in the pipeline that I mentioned earlier. And then in 2025, because again we've done a great job of proactively managing our rent roll, we only have about 162,000 square feet of vacates and 113,000 square feet of undecideds. And that's again, that's against the backdrop of over 820,000 square feet of leasing that we typically have done in the past three years in our Manhattan office portfolio. So, it may fluctuate quarter-to-quarter, but you see the trend that we've been on for the last two and a half years, we're well positioned going from now and into 2025 to continue to make progress on our lease percentage. And as our lease percentage climbs, our occupancy percentage will follow.
Tony Malkin: And I'd add there will always be variations, but when you look at our forward numbers, as Tom described, we do manage and early renewals are a part of this as we as tenants expand, we renew and extend their existing leases. So we're super active on these activities. And recognize something else, Camille, we don't wait for tenants' leases to expire to be active. So we do a lot of leasing of tenants who say I've got excess space. So, before they ever get to the point where they want to vacate, we work with them to lease their space while they're still in occupancy directly to a new tenant. So a lot of work in this regard and a lot of opportunity for us. We're just very, very happy with how the market receives our product and where we go with this.
Operator: Our next question comes from the line of Dylan Burzinski with Green Street. Please proceed with your question.
Dylan Burzinski: Just wanted to touch on the reaffirmation of 2024 FFO guidance. I mean, you guys are doing this acquisition that's expected to close in 3Q. You guys raised same property cash NOI growth guidance. So just curious sort of on the decision on deciding to reaffirm guidance given some of those positive characteristics that I just mentioned? I mean, what are some of the offsets to that? I know you guys mentioned G&A possibly being higher. So, sort of just curious anything else that we might be missing?
Steve Horn: Sure. This is Steve here. So, yes, our $0.04 FFO guidance range is meant to capture a variety of scenarios. And some of those live within the Observatory. We have tourism fluctuations and bad weather days to deal with. And our revenue there our NOI -- sorry, is split typically 40% in the first half of the year to 60% in the second half of the year. So even though we're halfway through the year. The Observatory's performance there will have an outsized impact in the second half of the year. As far as the transactions and capital markets activity, if you recall in the first quarter's call, we did note that with the new term loan in the facility [Indiscernible] buyout and the FSP sale had about a $0.01 dilutive impact on FFO. And there was also about $0.035 -- sorry $3.5 million of onetime items that benefit revenues within the first half of the year that we don't expect to recur in the second. So, with all that in mind, we still feel good about our FFO guidance not changing and sticking to that $0.90 to $0.94 share. As far as G&A, we already had that modeled in our FFO guidance for the year. Just calling it out as a benefit for models for ‘25.
Dylan Burzinski: Great. Appreciate the details.
Operator: We will now turn the call back to Tony Malkin, Chairman and CEO, for some closing remarks.
Tony Malkin: Okay. As we move forward, ESRT's priorities are to lease space, sell tickets to the Observatory, manage the balance sheet and achieve our sustainability goals. These actions together enhance shareholder value. We are pure play New York City more so now that we have honed our portfolio, four diverse ways to play it. Our office portfolio, top of tier in the deepest market segment, our number one ranked Observatory, our growing everyday street retail and our multifamily platform. We are a future ready portfolio and opportunity ready balance sheet. We have options today. We're in a position to take advantage of opportunities created through market disruptions and capital dislocation. We're confident in our team's ability to execute on our goals and drive further growth for our shareholders. I want to thank the team on the call today and who people who work every single day incredibly hard. We have confidence in you. And we'll continue to do a great job on behalf of our shareholders. I want to take a moment and do a special call out to board member, Grant Hill. The entire company and the Board are in support of our fellow board member, Grant Hill, who's Managing Director of the United States Men's Basketball team in the Paris Summer Olympics. Grant, we wish you all the best. We'll be cheering for you. Finally, I'd like to thank everybody for the participation in today's call. We look forward for the chance to meet with many of you at non-deal roadshows we'll be going to Europe in the fall, conferences, property tours in the months ahead. Until then, thank you very much for your interest and onward and upward.
Operator: Ladies and gentlemen, this does conclude today's teleconference. You may disconnect your lines at this time. Thank you for your participation and have a wonderful day.
This article was generated with the support of AI and reviewed by an editor. For more information see our T&C.